Who pays a court-auction condo's unpaid building management fees? How to read the three-document set
The buyer does. A former owner's unpaid building management fees and repair reserve fund survive the auction, and by the time you buy they may exceed the figure in the three-document set. Build them into your bidding limit.
Do unpaid building management fees disappear at auction?
No. The buyer pays the former owner's unpaid building management fees (kanrihi) and repair reserve fund (shuzen tsumitatekin). BIT, the courts' auction information site, says so in its glossary entry on delinquent debts: when you buy a condominium unit, the building management fees, repair reserve fund and other delinquent debts from before your purchase are paid by the buyer.
It usually comes to light late. You find a condo in a Tokyo District Court auction on BIT. Its base sale price (baikyaku kijun kakaku) is well below nearby closed sales, and the bid opening date is two weeks away. Only after your bid wins does the owners' association (kanri kumiai) send a statement of arrears, showing that the former owner had paid nothing toward either for several years.
The legal basis is in the Act on Building Unit Ownership. Article 7(1) covers claims against other unit owners under the management rules (kanri kiyaku) or general meeting resolutions, including the building management fees and repair reserve fund set by the rules. These claims can also be made against a successor in title (tokutei shokeinin), and an auction buyer counts as one (Act on Building Unit Ownership, Art. 8).
The sale does extinguish security interests such as statutory liens (sakidori tokken) and mortgages (teitoken) (Civil Execution Act, Art. 59). That includes the lien the owners' association holds under Article 7 of the Act on Building Unit Ownership. Only the security goes. The claim for the unpaid fees remains and can still be made against the buyer under Article 8.
What is in the three-document set?
The three-document set (santen setto) is three documents the court keeps on file, and you can download them from BIT. The descriptions below follow the BIT glossary.
Property specification
The property specification (bukken meisaisho) is prepared by the court clerk (Civil Execution Act, Art. 62; Rules of Civil Execution, Art. 31). It records five items: the description of the property; an outline of any statutory superficies (hotei chijoken); rights of others that the buyer will have to bear; special notes on occupancy and similar matters; and other matters useful for the purchase. The last three matter most: rights such as leases that pass to the buyer, who occupies the property, and other reference matters. BIT also notes that the specification does not determine anyone's legal rights, and what it says may change later.
Status survey report
A court execution officer writes the status survey report (genkyo chosa hokokusho) after an on-site investigation. It shows who occupies the property and whether they have a legal right to occupy it, with photos attached.
Appraisal report
In the appraisal report (hyokasho), an appraiser, normally a licensed real estate appraiser, sets out the valuation and how it was calculated. Read the report itself to see how the unpaid fees are treated and whether a deduction is stated, rather than assume they have been deducted. The BIT entry on payment of the price also lists delinquent debts as a cost the buyer bears on top of the price.
How much should you allow for arrears when you bid?
Allow for the arrears as they stand when you buy, not as the documents record them. The same BIT entry warns that the arrears recorded in the property specification, the appraisal report and similar documents may have kept growing by the time of purchase.
Before you bid:
- Ask the owners' association for the latest arrears, including what the management rules say about late charges. The management company may not answer someone who is not an owner. If you get no answer, estimate the figure as the amount in the three-document set plus the monthly charges that have fallen due since.
- Check the general meeting minutes for any one-off repair reserve levy (ichijikin) that has already been resolved.
- Estimate the costs after handover for clearing out the unit, changing the locks and restoring the interior.
Subtract all of this from the price you had in mind. What is left is your bidding limit. Bidding procedures and payment deadlines are covered on our auction page.
What we do
Give us a case number and we download the three-document set. We summarize, point by point, the five items in the property specification, the occupancy situation and how the appraisal report treats the unpaid fees. We then contact the management company for you about the latest arrears and any planned repairs. If we get no answer, we estimate as described above, and we work out the bidding limit with you. If it is unclear who has what rights in the property, a Japanese attorney (bengoshi) we work with reviews the file.
Further reading: Buying a pre-owned Tokyo condo? Check the management before the interior · Leasehold, no-rebuild and nonconforming properties: why they are cheap and what they cost you