Sell or rent an inherited property? Two property types, two sets of math
A pre-owned condo in central Tokyo and an old detached house need different math. Selling turns on time to sell and tax-break windows; renting turns on vacancy, repairs, management costs and withholding. Run both paths with your own numbers.
Which kind of property did you inherit?
Usually it is one of two types: a pre-owned condominium unit (chuko mansion) in central Tokyo, or an older detached house (ikkodate) in the suburbs or an older part of the city. The two call for different math.
Pre-owned condominium unit
There is an owners' association (kanri kumiai). The building management fee (kanrihi) and the repair reserve fund (shuzen tsumitatekin) are charged every month, the association handles building repairs, and tenants usually expect less of the landlord. When you sell, buyers look closely at how well the building is managed. The ¥30,000,000 vacant house deduction (National Tax Agency Tax Answer No. 3306) excludes properties with condominium-type unit registration, so it does not apply. For an inherited condominium, the main rule to look at is the acquisition cost add-on (Tax Answer No. 3267).
Older detached house
There is no owners' association, so the roof, exterior walls and boundary walls are all the owner's job. A house completed on or before May 31, 1981 that meets the conditions may qualify for the ¥30,000,000 vacant house deduction, and selling within the window may work out better on tax. Renting it out usually means a round of repairs first, so the outlay is large and the payback slow.
What goes into the math for selling?
It depends on how long the sale takes, the tax due and the time windows for the special rules.
- Time to sell: In the Tokyo metropolitan area, pre-owned condominiums took an average of 82.5 days from listing on REINS, the brokers' shared listing system, to a signed contract, and detached houses 100.9 days (2025 data). That is roughly three months.
- Tax: Tax is due on the capital gain on the sale (joto shotoku). If you have owned the property for more than 5 years as of January 1 of the year of sale, the gain is long-term, and income tax and resident tax together come to 20.315%. Five years or less is short-term, at 39.63% in total. Both rates include the special income tax for reconstruction and related taxes (Tax Answer No. 3208 and No. 3211). For an inherited property, the holding period counts from the date the deceased acquired it (Tax Answer No. 3270). The gain is calculated after deducting the acquisition cost and selling expenses. If the acquisition cost is unknown, 5% of the sale price can be used.
- Time windows: The ¥30,000,000 rule runs to December 31, 2027. The acquisition cost add-on runs about 3 years and 10 months from the start of inheritance. The article on tax breaks for selling inherited property in this series has the details.
What goes into the math for renting?
It depends on vacancy, repairs, tax and the property manager's fee.
- Vacancy: There is no income while you look for a tenant, but the building management fee, the repair reserve fund and fixed asset tax (kotei shisanzei, the annual property tax) are still due.
- Repairs: An older detached house usually needs a round of work on the roof, exterior walls and plumbing before it can be let.
- Tax: For an owner living abroad, the tenant usually withholds 20.42% of the rent at source (gensen choshu) (Tax Answer No. 2884; an individual renting a home for themselves or a relative to live in is excepted). You also need to appoint a tax agent for nonresidents (nozei kanrinin) (Tax Answer No. 1923) and file an annual tax return (kakutei shinkoku) every year.
- Property manager's fee: A management company charges a fee for looking after the rental, and rates vary. Compare quotes first.
Side by side, selling brings a single cash payment, tax is filed in the year of sale, and the special rules have windows. Renting brings monthly cash flow, but you carry the cost of vacancy, repairs and management up front, a return is filed every year, and once the windows close the special rules are gone. Which works out better depends on the property type, the year of completion (kenchiku nen), the number of heirs and how long you plan to hold.
What we do
We run both paths on the actual details of the property. For selling: the likely time to sell, the brokerage fee, capital gains tax and any special rules available. For renting: the likely rent, months of vacancy, repairs, management costs and withholding.
You get the two tables side by side, and you choose.
- Inheritance registration in Japan: a 3-year deadline that applies even if you live abroad
- Estate division agreements with heirs abroad: one unreachable heir stalls all the paperwork
- Do you owe Japanese inheritance tax? The basic exemption, the 10-month deadline and penalties
- Leaving an inherited house empty: what it costs each year
- Selling an inherited house: two tax breaks with different time windows
- An inherited Japanese house you do not want: three months to accept or renounce