Move-out and repairs: how much of the security deposit can be kept

Keeping the whole security deposit at move-out and billing repairs without photos are the two most common causes of disputes with tenants and managers. The reference points are MLIT's restoration guidelines and Civil Code Articles 621 and 622-2.

Prospect Real Estate·November 7, 2026

Where move-out disputes start

Most disputes start in one of two ways. In the first, the manager keeps the whole security deposit (shikikin). A tenant lives in the unit for a few years, and at move-out the management company deducts the entire deposit for "cleaning and wallpaper replacement." The tenant objects, and a dispute begins.

In the second, a repair is billed with no photos. The charge appears with no before-and-after photos and no quote. The tenant says it is normal wear, the landlord says it is damage, and without evidence nobody can settle it.

Who pays for restoration?

The landlord pays for normal wear and aging. That is the approach of the Guidelines on Restoration to Original Condition published by the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism (MLIT), which cover restoring the unit at move-out (genjo kaifuku). The Civil Code takes the same position: it excludes wear from ordinary use and aging of the property from the tenant's duty to restore (Civil Code, Art. 621).

Dents from furniture and fading from sunlight are normal wear. Deliberate damage, nicotine staining from smoking and damage from a pet's chewing are the tenant's responsibility. If the lease has a special clause making the tenant bear more, the case law cited in the guidelines requires that both sides clearly agreed to it. A line tucked into a corner of the contract is not enough.

Does the tenant pay the full cost of their damage?

No. The guidelines reduce the tenant's share according to how many years the item has been in use, and in practice the years of occupancy are often used instead. The longer the tenant has lived there, the smaller the share. The guidelines' example is wallpaper and carpet with a 6-year useful life, whose value falls to ¥1 at the end of that period. A tenant who deliberately damages an item past its useful life may still have to pay for the repair, however. For spot repairs to flooring, the guidelines say the age-based reduction does not apply.

How the deposit is settled

When the lease ends and the unit has been handed back, the landlord must return the deposit minus what the tenant owes (Civil Code, Art. 622-2). So settlement happens in this order: confirm the unit has been returned, work out what the tenant owes, and return the balance. The settlement sheet lists each deduction with the item, the amount and how it was reduced for age, with photos attached, and goes to the landlord with the monthly report.

Records to keep at move-out and for repairs

Joint move-out inspection. On move-out day, the manager, the tenant and, when needed, the contractor walk through the unit together. They take photos on the spot, record each point, and ask the tenant to sign to confirm.

Approval for large jobs. For full wallpaper replacement, floor repairs, equipment replacement and similar large jobs, get quotes from two or three contractors and have the quotes sent to you. The amount that counts as large is written into the contract. Anything above your authorized limit needs your written approval before work starts.

Repair records. Keep the quote, before-and-after photos and invoice for every repair. A year of records can go straight to your licensed tax accountant (zeirishi).

What we do

Before a tenant moves out, we check the special clauses in the lease against the MLIT guidelines. We list separately what can be charged to the tenant and what the landlord bears, and work out the tenant's share using the guidelines' age-based reduction. On inspection day we photograph everything for the file. You receive the settlement sheet with the monthly report, and large repairs come to you for approval once we have compared quotes.

PhoneBook a visit