Setting an asking price: why closed sales matter more than the highest valuation

Broker valuations often differ by 10% to 20%, and the highest can be a bid to win your listing. Overprice a home and buyers watch every price cut, and it often sells for less than a realistic first price would have achieved.

Prospect Real Estate·November 7, 2026

What happens if you choose the highest valuation?

Often, a longer sale and a lower price. Many sellers ask three brokers for a valuation (satei) and sign with whoever quotes highest. A valuation is not a sale price. It is the broker's view of roughly what the property could fetch, and a spread of 10% to 20% between brokers is not unusual. The highest quote is sometimes genuine optimism, and sometimes a way to win the listing first and suggest a price cut once the home is on the market.

The cost of pricing too high is time. According to East Japan REINS statistics for 2025, pre-owned condos in the Tokyo metropolitan area took an average of 82.5 days from registration on REINS, the brokers' shared listing system, to a signed contract, and detached houses (ikkodate) took 100.9 days. If your home has been listed for three or four months without a deal, buyers and their brokers can see online how long it has been up and how many times the price has changed. That price history becomes a bargaining chip in itself: they are in no hurry, and they wait for the next cut.

What to compare prices against

Closed sales (seiyaku jirei). Prices actually achieved in the last year or two, in the same building or the same area, for units of similar size and age. Your broker can pull closed-sale records from REINS. The Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism also publishes transaction prices in its Real Estate Information Library (reinfolib.mlit.go.jp), which you can search yourself without waiting for a broker.

Asking prices. These show what other sellers want, not what buyers will pay. If you use them as a reference, also check how long those homes have been listed and whether their prices have been cut.

How each valuation was built. Ask every broker to state which closed sales they used, how they adjusted for floor and orientation, and what they deducted. A valuation that cannot name its comparables has nothing behind its number. A broker who gives an opinion on price must also explain the basis for it (Real Estate Brokerage Act, Art. 34-2(2)).

How to set the first asking price

Set it at the upper end of the closed-sale range, with a little room to negotiate, rather than well above it. Most viewings happen in the first few weeks after listing. If there are almost no viewing requests in the first four to six weeks, the problem is usually the price, not the season.

When to cut the price, and by how much

Agree on the price-cut points in advance. If there are no viewings after a set number of weeks, review the listing, and then make one cut to the right level. Avoid repeated small cuts of a few hundred thousand yen. Each small cut tells buyers the price is still falling, while one cut to an attractive price tends to sell faster.

How to check a valuation yourself

Look up closed prices in the Real Estate Information Library for the same area, with similar size and age. Set them beside the comparables in each valuation. You will see quickly whether the prices sit in the same range, and whether a valuation has been padded.

What we do

Our starting point is a price range built from closed sales. We put together a comparison table of closed prices in the same building and area, how long each took to sell and how many price cuts each went through. We set it beside the valuations you already have and show which have a basis and which are simply a high number. Then we agree on the first price and the price-cut points with you and write them into our sales plan.

PhoneBook a visit