General, exclusive or exclusive-exclusive: which listing agreement to sign when you sell
Under a general listing, no broker has much reason to push your home, and under an exclusive listing, one broker may keep it from others. The three types differ in term, REINS registration and reporting duties, so match them to your property.
The three types of listing agreement
To sell through a broker, you sign a listing agreement (baikai keiyaku). There are three types: general (ippan baikai), exclusive (sennin baikai) and exclusive-exclusive (senzoku sennin baikai). Many sellers do not compare them. They sign whichever one the broker hands them and find the problem later.
A general listing lets you appoint several brokers at once. That sounds like more choice, but each broker knows it may not be paid even if the home sells, so none wants to spend much on advertising or staff time. An exclusive or exclusive-exclusive listing goes to one broker, which gives that broker a reason to work hard on it.
The risk with an exclusive listing: keeping it in-house
The risk is keeping the listing in-house (kakoikomi). The broker holds your property and also wants to find the buyer itself, so that it is paid by both sides. When other brokers ask about the property, they are told "we already have a buyer," and outside buyers are turned away. The result is that your home reaches far fewer potential buyers.
Rules for exclusive and exclusive-exclusive listings
The law sets three rules for the two exclusive types: a maximum term, registration on REINS and regular reports (Real Estate Brokerage Act, Art. 34-2).
Term. An exclusive or exclusive-exclusive agreement runs for 3 months at most. It can be renewed only at the seller's request (paragraph 4), and each renewal is also limited to 3 months. A special clause providing for automatic renewal in breach of these rules is void (paragraph 10).
REINS registration. The broker must register the property on REINS, the brokers' shared listing system, within 7 days of signing an exclusive agreement, not counting the broker's days off, or within 5 days for exclusive-exclusive. After registering, the broker must give you a document certifying the registration (paragraph 6). Other brokers can then see your property on REINS, which is the first barrier against keeping it in-house.
Activity reports. The broker must report at least once every 2 weeks under an exclusive listing, and at least once a week under exclusive-exclusive. The statute does not say what a report must contain, so you can ask for the agreement to require the number of inquiries, the number of viewings and buyer feedback. Under any type of agreement, the broker must also tell you without delay when a buyer submits an offer (paragraph 8).
Which type should you choose?
General listing. Worth considering if you want several brokers working at once and the property is strong enough to draw viewers anyway, such as a small unit in a popular area. You will need to track progress yourself.
Exclusive listing. Suits you if you want one broker who is committed to the sale and reports on a fixed schedule. This is the most common choice.
Exclusive-exclusive listing. Differs from exclusive in one point: if you find a buyer yourself, you cannot sell to them directly without going through the broker. It is usually chosen only when you are sure you will not find a buyer on your own.
What to confirm before you sign
Whichever type you choose, the agreement should state the price and the fee. Brokerage fees on a sale have a legal cap. For a price over ¥4,000,000, the cap can be calculated with the shortcut formula "price × 3% + ¥60,000," plus consumption tax. For a ¥30,000,000 home, that is ¥960,000 plus tax.
Before you sign, also confirm:
- that the REINS registration certificate will reach you on time;
- how often reports will come;
- that keeping the listing in-house is ruled out, for example by requiring the broker to answer other brokers' inquiries truthfully and not turn them away with "we already have a buyer."
What we do
We set out the differences between the three types, their terms and the registration rules on one page, applied to your property. Then we go through the clauses in each draft agreement your brokers give you, looking at the registration deadline, the reporting frequency and how renewal works. After you sign, we also check the registration certificate and each report against the agreement, to see that the broker is doing what the agreement requires.
- Selling Tokyo property from overseas: the seven steps
- Setting an asking price: why closed sales matter more than the highest valuation
- Selling a home with a loan outstanding: payoff, mortgage release and settlement day
- Seller disclosure: the fixtures list, the property condition form and what happens if you leave something out
- Selling Japanese property while living abroad: signature certificates, 10.21% withholding and the refund
- Tax on selling property in Japan: holding period, the ¥30,000,000 deduction and acquisition cost
- Selling with a tenant in place: handing over the security deposit, the lease and the management contract